The Dependent Generation

So, I’m a teacher. Have I men­tio­ned that before? I currently teach two days a week and I have a fan­tas­tic team part­ner who teaches the addi­tio­nal three days. I’ve been a teacher since I was 21. So for the last nine years I’ve had the plea­sure of coming into con­tact with many dif­fe­rent chil­dren and parents. And I’ve lear­ned a lot.

Today as I was scro­lling through my Goo­gle Rea­der, I came upon Sara’s post from Subur­ban Obli­vion. She recently wrote about being, or rather not being, the per­fect parent. Today she piggy­bac­ked on this post by wri­ting about kids who play inde­pen­dently vs. the ones whose parents are their playmate.

She wri­tes:

I remem­ber being as young as two or three pla­ying outside by myself in a yard that not only was unfen­ced, but had train tracks run­ning through the very back of the lot. I can feel the gasps from here– How did you ever sur­vive?? Back then there was a clear line bet­ween kids and adults. Kids pla­yed, adults did wha­te­ver adults did. Adults did not sche­dule their entire lives around what the kids wan­ted. If they could work it in, great. If not, oh well. I can’t ima­gine a per­son of my parents gene­ra­tion spen­ding the entire day shutt­ling kids back and forth to school, sports and play­da­tes, even if they WERE a stay at home mom. Yet like so many of my own gene­ra­tion, that is exactly how my time is spent.

I’ve often strug­gled with this as well. I don’t always enjoy pla­ying outside with my kids. I hate pla­ying trains, and most of all, I hate when my kids can’t be inde­pen­dent. I know, I know. Rank me up there as a ‘bad parent’ but I don’t care. I have s**t to do! On top of rea­ring my kids, I have a house to manage, finan­ces to keep up on, a hus­band to love, and a body to keep healthy. My sole job is not cate­ring to my kids every whim.

So now I’ll bring this back to teaching. I have noti­ced that the kids these days are very dif­fe­rent from the stu­dents of past gene­ra­tions. Stu­dents con­ti­nually feel like it is their right to have an ongoing per­so­nal dia­lo­gue with the teacher, whe­ne­ver they see fit. Often, very often, an assign­ment will be given and before a he even begins, the stu­dent is up at my desk saying, “I don’t get it.” As if trying but not com­ple­ting the pro­ject exactly the way the teacher might want it would be a fai­lure. Most teachers are so fle­xi­ble, that we will take anything that resem­bles the pre­vious directions.

It’s been know to hap­pen that when giving my stu­dents free time, I have a child-or ten, come up and ask if I want to play with them. Uh, no! I don’t. Go make friends your own age!

I’m pretty sure that there are a few fac­tors that lend them­sel­ves to this gro­wing gene­ra­tion of depen­dent children.

1. Nanny’s hel­ping to raise our kids. Can you ima­gine saying to your nanny, “Uh, ya. Can you allow my child to play inde­pen­dently? Feel free to watch a bit of TV today ins­tead…” No, we expect them to enter­tain our kids! I know I do, each Mon­day that our nanny comes over.

2. Parents fee­ling the need to be play­mate to their kids.

3. Sma­ller families.-giving us more time to devote to each child.

Some­ti­mes the guilt over­ta­kes us. I’ve been know to say to myself, “But BC is so dis­traught that I won’t go outside and watch him go down the slide.…”

Ulti­ma­tely, I believe that by teaching our kids to be inde­pen­dent, we are arming them with good tools to become suc­cess­ful, strong, secure, and con­fi­dent people.

3 Comments

  1. Lady M said,

    May 16, 2007 @ 11:54 pm

    Good thoughts. It’s tricky, wan­ting to be sup­por­tive and let­ting them grow up too.

  2. Jenny said,

    May 17, 2007 @ 12:13 am

    well said. it’s a tricky issue, for sure! i guess it’s a sign of how for­tu­nate we are if the issue we deal with is having TOO MUCH time for our kids!

  3. Sha Sha said,

    May 17, 2007 @ 1:57 pm

    Amen, Sis­ter!

    I always feel bad that I don’t want to get on the ground and play with the kid­dos. I must be a bad parent for not wan­ting to. But I too think that it is very impor­tant for them to be inde­pen­dent, even bet­ter, to want to play with their siblings! That’s one rea­son I love living where I live! THey have to play with eachother because we have no neighbors!

    When are we going to see you guys again?
    Talk to you soon!

RSS feed for comments on this post · TrackBack URI